Wednesday, July 19, 2006

A Bit More on Faction Imbalance

Azreal posted a very detailed and interesting comment to the post about faction imbalance. It's well worth reading, and I'm still chewing on a lot of the nuances. However, I'd like to zero in on one idea:

Each encounter requires you do a set amount of DPS in a certain time frame in a controlled environment.

Here are my thoughts:

1. For this game to be at all balanced, a Horde raid must be able to do the same raid-wide DPS as an Alliance raid.

2. However, a single Alliance DPS class can always do more damage than a single Horde DPS class. If the encounter is threat-limited, Blessing of Salvation enables the extra damage. If the encounter is not threat-limited, Blessing of Wisdom, Might, and Kings allow for more DPS than the shaman totem equivalents.

The only way to reconcile statements 1 and 2 is for the Horde raid to get additional DPS from another source. The only possible source that a Horde raid can draw DPS from, which the Alliance cannot also tap, is shamans.

So there are three possibilities:

1. Shamans are expected to add some DPS.

OR

2. Shaman Totems enable as much extra DPS as Paladin Blessings.

OR

3. Blizzard has deliberately made an unbalanced game.

I'm pretty sure that we are all in agreement that Possibility #2 is wrong.

As for Possibility #3, I do not think that Blizzard--the makers of Starcraft--would think that making a game with two factions, where one faction is strictly better than the other faction, is a good idea.

So by a process of elimination, the only possibility left is that Blizzard expects shamans to add DPS. I do not see any other logical explanation for raid and class design.

4 comments:

Shockfury said...

its a dead horse topic, personally im just tired of people talking about this and how everything should be nice and fair. It's pretty much as dead as paladins getting more changes. Eyonix pretty much said "we will be lookiing over the next few patches at how these things work out making improvements across the board"..something he said after the paladin patch. Learning from the past, it means we wont do jack squat. Blizzard was never too good at balance in this game.

Inframike said...

In fairness,

4. Shamans are expected to be better healers than Paladins, enabling more members of the raid to stay up longer to apply their DPS.

Heh.

Anonymous said...

It may not seem like much, but people forget about racials when they do these calculations. Both trolls and Orcs have the ability to "up the damage." Please factor racials in, as well.

GSH said...

4. Shamans are expected to be better healers than Paladins, enabling more members of the raid to stay up longer to apply their DPS.

While this may be true, a lot of the newer encounters are timed. The boss enrages and becomes unkillable after 5 minutes or whatever. So the raidwide DPS over those 5 minutes has to match.

As for racials, I don't think any racials are really *that* different. Plus, you can't really expect X orcs to be in the raid, the way you can expect 5 warriors. As well, humans have +swords/maces, which ups the damage on bosses.